No. Hollyhock (Alcea rosea) is not a hibiscus. It belongs to the same family, the mallow family (Malvaceae), but it is a different genus. The two plants look somewhat alike, especially from a distance. Their growth, flower centres, leaves and fruit are different.
Same family, different genus
Hollyhock was once called Althaea rosea. It is now placed in the genus Alcea, which belongs to the tribe Malveae. Hibiscus belongs to a different tribe, Hibisceae. Sharing a family explains why the two look alike, but it does not make them the same plant.
Growth habit: spike or shrub
Hollyhock is usually a biennial or a short-lived perennial. In its first year it forms a rosette of leaves at ground level. In its second year it sends up a tall flowering spike, typically 5 to 8 feet (1.5 to 2.5 m), with blooms along the stem.
Hibiscus generally grows as a bushy shrub or a clump-forming perennial. Its flowers come singly in the leaf axils or near the shoot tips. It does not have a single tall flower spike.
Flowers
- Size. Hollyhock flowers are about 3 to 5 inches (8 to 13 cm) across. Hardy hibiscus flowers are bigger, at 6 to 12 inches (15 to 30 cm), but tropical hibiscus flowers can be as small as 3 inches. Size alone does not settle it.
- Centre. Hibiscus has a long, protruding staminal column with five stigma lobes at the tip. Hollyhock has a short central boss with many stigmas.
- Colour. Hollyhock comes in yellow, apricot and near-black (‘Nigra’). Hardy hibiscus does not come in yellow. Tropical hibiscus does, so yellow alone cannot tell you which plant you have.
- Opening. Hollyhock flowers open from the bottom of the spike upward.
Leaves and fruit
- Leaves. Hollyhock leaves are rounded, shallowly lobed and rough-hairy, and they grow from a basal rosette. Hibiscus leaves grow alternately up the stem.
- Fruit. Hollyhock forms a flat disc of many wedge-shaped segments, like a cheese wheel. Hibiscus forms a five-chambered capsule that splits open.
The fruit and the flower centre are the most reliable tells.
Shared traits and mix-ups
Hollyhock and hibiscus share some features. Both have large flowers, both attract Japanese beetles, and both have edible flowers. Hollyhocks self-sow freely, so plants grown from seed vary.
Two common sources of confusion:
- “Althea”. Rose of Sharon is not a hollyhock, but both are sometimes called “althea”.
- Old names. Hollyhock was once placed in Althaea, which is also the genus of marsh mallow.
Hollyhocks are prone to rust, a fungal disease. It is mainly a hollyhock problem. It rarely affects hibiscus, though this is less well documented.
Quick comparison
| Feature | Hollyhock (Alcea rosea) | Hibiscus |
|---|---|---|
| Growth | Biennial or short-lived perennial, with a tall single spike | Bushy shrub or clump-forming perennial |
| Flower position | Along a tall spike, opening from the bottom | Singly in leaf axils or near shoot tips |
| Flower centre | Short central boss with many stigmas | Long staminal column with five stigma lobes |
| Leaves | Rounded, shallowly lobed, rough-hairy, from a basal rosette | Alternate up the stem |
| Fruit | Flat disc of wedge-shaped segments | Five-chambered capsule |
Common misconceptions
- Hollyhock is not a hibiscus.
- Most hollyhocks are not long-lived perennials. They are usually biennial.
- Rose of Sharon is not a hollyhock, though both are sometimes called “althea”.
- Similar flowers do not mean the same genus. The fruit and the flower centre tell them apart.
For the wider family picture, see our hibiscus types overview. For another relative in the same family, see our okra and hibiscus article.